Before Chicago media focused on the Blagojevich trial, it spent some time on airport body scanners at O’Hare. Alas, I flew out of Milwaukee, which, it turns out, also has body scanners.
So it is a little before 6am on a Tuesday morning, and having experienced an extremely sluggish computer terminal for check-in, I find myself facing a quickly growing security line. Why is it growing so quickly? Because Milwaukee has one metal detector and one body scanner open. It took a second for the body scanner to register. It doesn’t look intimidating at all and its grayish coloring makes it blend rather nicely next to the metal detector. Not to mention the baggage scanner and the other gray matter that makes up the security check point. The only color is that of passengers in white, red, orange, green or powder blue shirts. If you’re not looking for it, you’ll likely miss the body scanner.
Having spotted it, I opted to empty my pockets while I was still standing in line. I even took off my belt. No one had passed through it yet, but it seemed reasonable to expect at least one of the 20 people in front of me to pass through it, increasing my odds of passing through it as well. It only takes one, after all, right?
Idling in line with my boarding pass and driver’s license, it seemed clear that Milwaukee does not quite have its act together this morning. Once you get checked by a rather cranky official, you’re left to ponder if you should get in the screening line on the right, or on the left. No official points or directs you, they just kind of look at you and half nod when you start to move in a direction. Course, by the time I get up there, someone has taken charge, noticing that the line to the left is decidedly longer than the line on the right. Except people from either line were going through the metal detector while the body scanner sat there, gray, sullen and empty.
Not this trip, perhaps, I thought to myself as I followed the direction to get in line on the right and watch as one brave soul stands in front of the body scanner, points to himself and then to it, causing a TSA official to half nod.
It does, in fact, take one to start something.
Perhaps he was in a hurry and thought the body scanner would be faster than the 8-deep line for the metal detector. Who can say really, but in he stepped, up his hands went, down they came and out he went. He was held for a couple minutes by a TSA official, then motioned to go collect his belongings.
I had two thoughts: that was fast! And: if the government has a body image now, along with all the other information collected, can they please present me with a complete profile so I don’t have to go through all this again? Require me to get re-scanned every 5 years or every 5,000 miles to verify or record any changes, but since so much information has been collected, complete with a body scan, why will I have to do this again?
These thoughts bounced around my head as I, too, stood with my hands up in the body scanner. I don’t know quite know what, if anything, I expected. I didn’t feel foolish, standing there with my hands in the air as if I was behind held up. There wasn’t anything to look at outside the glass, just the unused metal detector and other body scanner. There was a faint noise. Faint, as passengers getting ready to go through the metal detector make a fair amount of noise. The experience was lackluster, to say the least, but a little quicker than the metal detector.
I stepped out and was held for a couple minutes until someone, somewhere, radioed the all clear. So somewhere in General Mitchell Airport is a person, or two, sitting in front of a bank of monitors, staring at whatever image of me was just collected. No weapons, explosives or anything out of the ordinary on my person, or perhaps inside, so I was free to go and collect my things.
Not much different from a metal detector, on the face of things.
Again, I thought, now that there is an image of me, why can’t I pass through security that much more quickly? Such a luxury isn’t afforded by metal detectors since they can’t store images of any kind.
And then I thought of WikiLeaks. Issues of compromised security and safety aside, WikiLeaks did what others have failed to do: it put all documents in one accessible location. You can find all the pieces and construct them yourself.
Now the government could do that, if it were inclined, with all the information it has on me, complete with a visual aide. At first thought, that sounds awesome. A good deal could be simplified if it took a couple of clicks to pull up a complete profile of me. Airport security. Passport renewal. Driver’s license renewal. Paying taxes. Almost anything that requires government involvement.
The thought of such a complete profile being kept by the government in one location makes me uneasy. What, exactly, would I be giving up? Control of my information? Maybe. There is an argument to be made that I have little control as it is, and am thus assuming a certain amount of risk. Like applying to jobs through CraigsList, or sending a resume via email. I’m trusting that the person on the other end isn’t going to do something beyond the scope of reviewing it for a potential match to vacancies.
I’m trusting the TSA, and the government, not to do anything else with the image they just collected. But what if I want the government to do something else with the image they just collected? What if I want the government to match it up and present me a complete profile of myself? I must admit, it is intriguing and a bit scary. But if it means I’m cleared through airport security in a flash for the next 5 years or 5,000 miles, it might just be worth it.
All in all, passing through the body scanner was just as uneventful as passing through the metal detector. It is only after you have been asked to step out and are held for a couple minutes that it takes on more meaning that a metal detector. Instead of a light flashing telling TSA to check you out, there is a person unseen checking you out and deciding if a further search is necessary. That extra human element that you cannot see gives pause when confronted with a body scanner.